Recognise these four maps?
I'm sure you do, for they're all but ubiquitous - they have found their way into the handouts of anti-Israel organisations, decorate many Israel-delegitimising websites, and take pride of place on the stall the local Palestine Solidarity Campaign - a veritable witches' coven if ever there was one - sets up in my town on a regular basis, to demonstrate to passersby, many of whom are university students, just how much "Palestinian" land those big bad Zionists have grabbed over the decades.
Not long ago, the redoubtable Elder of Ziyon, in a characteristically masterly and devastating analysis http://elderofziyon.blogspot.com/2011/03/map-that-lies-and-one-that-doesnt.html showed how mendacious those maps are, and substituted these accurate maps instead, which illustrate the concessions for peace that Israel has made since 1967:
And now, over at the ever-admirable CiF Watch, the always brilliant Israeli Nurse, setting herself the task of tracking the provenance of the four mendacious maps, has with Holmesian detective skills uncovered a trail that leads to a senior cleric within the Anglican Church.
Her piece is not to be missed! http://cifwatch.com/2011/06/24/beyond-belief-political-propaganda-in-the-anglican-church/#respond
Daphne
ReplyDeleteThe 'celebrated' artist Richard Hamilton used something very similar to these maps as the centrepiece of his exhibition at the Serpentine Gallery. I did an expose of this here:
http://edgar1981.blogspot.com/2010/04/anti-israel-propaganda-portraying-as.html
And as a result I produced my own alternative here:
http://edgar1981.blogspot.com/2010/04/expansionist-israel.html
Thanks, Edgar.
ReplyDeleteGreat stuff - I forgot about your maps but that is actually how I discovered your blog, googling maps.
Let's repeat the link:
http://edgar1981.blogspot.com/2010/04/expansionist-israel.html
G'day, to my two favourite bloggers, though I have only recently discovered 'Edgar', thanks to 'Daphne'
ReplyDeleteAnd g'day to my source extraordinaire! You're so often my "eyes and ears"!
ReplyDeleteYou might be interested in this debate over those maps?
ReplyDeletehttp://jimbuie.blogs.com/journal/2011/04/palestinian-loss-of-land-1946-2000.html
Great link!
ReplyDeleteMany thanks, Anon!
An excellent deconstruction of a very widely-used piece of propaganda. And as Edgar Davidson's map reminds us, there is already an independent Palestinian state on land making up 3/4 of the original Palestine mandate territory, land which has never been occupied or claimed by Israel.
ReplyDeleteIt's not a map, but I've discussed some of the same issues.
Thank you, Infidel - worth looking at:
ReplyDeletehttp://infidel753.blogspot.com/2010/03/israel.html